The Sandwich Shop Staten Island

Nestled in the heart of Staten Island, The Sandwich Shop Staten Island is a sanctuary for sandwich lovers craving expertly crafted, hearty, and flavorful handheld delights. This beloved sandwich shop offers a diverse menu that celebrates the spirit of classic American deli fare, elevated with creative twists and top-quality ingredients.

From the first bite, the food at The Sandwich Shop delivers an undeniable burst of freshness and robust flavor. Their Cuban Sandwich is a symphony of smoky, tender pork paired with tangy pickles and melted Swiss cheese, perfectly pressed on crisp Cuban bread. For those who crave a true taste of New York’s iconic deli culture, Lynn’s Reuben Sandwich, packed generously with corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and gooey melted cheese, offers an indulgent yet balanced experience. The Crispy Chicken Sandwich is a standout favorite, boasting a crunchy, golden exterior that gives way to tender, juicy chicken within—a true comfort food elevated to an art form. Seafood lovers will find the Shrimp Club Sandwich irresistible, with fresh shrimp tossed in herbed mayo complemented by crisp lettuce and ripe tomatoes.

The menu’s creativity extends beyond sandwiches into vibrant and fresh sides like house-cut French fries, golden onion rings, and the crave-worthy Crabby Fries—fries tossed in Old Bay seasoning and cheese sauce that balance zest and comfort in every bite. The accompanying salads, such as the Mixed Green or Tuna Salad Sandwich, are crafted with fresh ingredients that awaken the palate without overpowering the main event.

The Sandwich Shop offers an inviting atmosphere that feels both casual and meticulously maintained—an ideal spot for a quick lunch or a laid-back dinner. The friendly staff’s warmth and dedication shine through, as repeatedly echoed by the community of satisfied diners. Reviewer Weronika sums it up perfectly: “Truly no better sandwich shop. The food, the service, the quality, 5 stars across the board. Unmatched!” Meanwhile, Andy A’s enthusiasm highlights the consistency of excellence: “HIGHLY HIGHLY RECOMMENDED. If I could give them 10 Stars I absolutely would… super clean place.”

Whether stopping in for a comforting Chicago-Style Italian Steak Sandwich packed with flavorful braised beef or savoring the perfectly seasoned New York Famous Chopped Cheese, each sandwich is a celebration of layered textures and harmonious flavors. The home-cooked touches—such as housemade pickles, tender braised meats, and perfectly melted cheeses—amplify the authenticity of every offering.

Patrons also rave about the shop’s willingness to accommodate special requests, crafting each order with care and consideration. J Cee praises the freshness and homemade quality: “Absolutely amazing food! This is my new go-to spot for lunch and dinner... everything is homemade and it tastes it!!! P.S. BEST FRIES EVER.”

In a neighborhood filled with dining options, The Sandwich Shop Staten Island stands out as a beacon of genuine culinary craftsmanship and heartfelt service. From the first bite of a crispy, perfectly balanced sandwich to the final crispy fries, it’s clear this is a place where passion for good food meets community spirit. For anyone seeking satisfying, authentic sandwiches that delight the senses and warm the soul, this local gem is an unmissable destination.

Location: 61 Giffords Ln, Staten Island, NY 10308, United States
Phone: +1 718-269-7838